Have a performance review coming up? Whether you’re preparing for an annual evaluation or a regular check-in with your manager, the conversation is an opportunity to highlight your contributions, get useful feedback, and plan your next career move.

A performance review shouldn’t be a one-sided assessment of your work. It’s also your chance to discuss challenges, clarify expectations, and understand what it takes to progress professionally. The best results come when you prepare specific examples, ask thoughtful questions, and approach the conversation with an open mind.

As a legal recruiter based in Toronto working with professionals and employers, I know that career advancement involves more than simply doing your job well. You also need to communicate your value, understand your development opportunities, and demonstrate that you’re ready for what’s next.

Here’s my advice on six things to discuss in a performance review and four things to avoid saying.

How to Prepare for a Performance Review

Before meeting with your manager, take some time to review your accomplishments, responsibilities, and goals since your last evaluation.

The Government of Canada’s Job Bank guidance on managing employees emphasizes the importance of reviewing past accomplishments, identifying challenges, considering career goals, and discussing learning needs and support.

Use that approach to prepare a few notes covering:

  • Your achievements: Identify projects completed, targets achieved, and improvements you’ve contributed to.
  • Evidence of your impact: Gather relevant figures, client feedback, project outcomes, or examples of how your work benefited the organization.
  • Challenges: Think about what didn’t go as planned, what you learned, and what you would do differently.
  • Future goals: Consider the skills you want to develop and the responsibilities you’d like to take on.
  • Questions: Decide what you want to understand about your performance, priorities, and career opportunities.

You don’t need to prepare a presentation or defend every decision you’ve made. The goal is to have a productive conversation supported by clear examples.

Question to consider: How Long Should You Work Without a Raise or Promotion? 

6 Things to Discuss During a Performance Review

1. Your Achievements and Contributions

Your performance review is an opportunity to demonstrate the value you bring to your team and organization. Rather than simply listing your responsibilities, explain what you’ve accomplished and why it matters.

Whenever possible, use measurable results. For example, a sales professional might discuss beating quarterly targets, while a project manager could highlight a successful project that reduced costs or improved efficiency.

Consider contributions beyond your formal responsibilities, too. Have you helped onboard a new colleague, improved a team process, strengthened a client relationship, or taken the lead on a challenging project?

Specific examples help your manager understand your contribution and provide a stronger basis for discussing future responsibilities.

2. Your Skill Development and Training Needs

Discuss the skills you’ve developed and those that could help you become more effective in your current role.

You might have completed a certification, learned a new software platform, improved your communication skills, or gained experience managing projects. Explain how these developments have helped you perform better.

It’s equally important to identify areas where further training or experience would be beneficial. If you want to move into management, for example, you could ask about opportunities to lead projects, mentor colleagues, or develop your decision-making skills.

3. Challenges and How You Addressed Them

Every role comes with challenges. A performance review is an appropriate place to discuss them, particularly when they have affected your ability to meet expectations.

Explain the situation, what you did to address it, and what you learned. If a project missed a deadline because of changing requirements or resource constraints, for example, describe how you responded and what could improve the process in the future.

Be honest about your own contribution to the outcome. Acknowledging a mistake and explaining how you’ll avoid repeating it demonstrates accountability.

You should also raise unresolved issues that may affect future performance, such as unclear priorities, competing deadlines, or limited access to essential resources.

4. Feedback and Opportunities for Improvement

A performance review should be a two-way conversation. While your manager will likely share observations about your work, you should also ask for specific feedback.

General comments such as “you need to communicate better” aren’t particularly helpful without examples. Ask your manager to explain what effective communication would look like in your role and where they see room for improvement.

You can also discuss your strengths and how to use them more effectively.

Useful questions include:

  • What’s one thing I could do differently to improve my performance?
  • Which of my strengths should I be using more often?
  • Where have I fallen short of expectations?
  • What would stronger performance look like in my role?

Listen carefully, ask for clarification when needed, and take time to consider what you’ve heard. You don’t have to agree with every assessment, but understanding your manager’s perspective can help you decide what to do next.

5. Your Goals and Career Aspirations

A performance review is a natural opportunity to discuss where you want your career to go.

You may want to progress into a leadership position, specialize in a particular area, manage larger projects, or broaden your experience across the organization. Share those ambitions and ask what steps would help you move toward them.

Be realistic about the experience and skills required. Strong performance in your current position doesn’t automatically mean you’re ready for a more senior role. You may need to demonstrate strategic thinking, people management, commercial awareness, or the ability to handle greater responsibility.

You can also discuss timelines, potential development assignments, and how progress will be evaluated. Your manager may not be able to promise a promotion, but they should be able to help clarify expectations and identify possible next steps.

6. Workplace Concerns and Support You Need

If something is preventing you from doing your best work, raise it constructively.

This might include competing priorities, insufficient resources, unclear responsibilities, workload concerns, or processes that create unnecessary delays. Explain how the issue affects your work and suggest practical ways to address it.

For example, if you’re regularly balancing several urgent projects, ask your manager to clarify which deliverables should take priority when deadlines conflict.

You can also discuss whether you have the tools, information, and support needed to meet expectations.

A performance review isn’t the only time to raise workplace concerns, and serious issues shouldn’t necessarily wait until your scheduled meeting. However, it can be a useful opportunity to discuss ongoing challenges and agree on improvements.

Headhunter insights: Didn’t Get the Raise or Promotion You Were Expecting? 7 Steps You Should Take 

4 Things Not to Say During a Performance Review

Knowing what to discuss is important, but how you respond to difficult feedback can be just as significant. Avoid these common mistakes.

1. Making Excuses Instead of Taking Responsibility

Avoid: “I didn’t meet the target because nobody gave me enough support.”

There may be legitimate reasons for falling short of an expectation. The problem is dismissing responsibility without explaining the circumstances or proposing a solution.

Instead, describe the obstacles, acknowledge what was within your control, and explain how you’ll approach the situation differently.

Try: “I struggled to meet the target because I didn’t have the resources I needed at the start. Next time, I’ll raise that concern earlier so we can address it before it affects delivery.”

2. Responding Negatively to Constructive Criticism

Avoid: “That’s not fair. I don’t see a problem with how I work.”

It’s natural to feel defensive when someone questions your performance. However, immediately dismissing feedback can prevent you from understanding the concern.

Listen first and ask for examples. If you disagree, explain your perspective calmly and use relevant evidence.

Try: “I understand your concern. Could you give me an example so I can better understand what I should change?”

You can acknowledge feedback without automatically agreeing with every conclusion.

3. Arguing Without Seeking Clarification

Avoid: “You’re wrong. That’s not what happened.”

If you believe an assessment is inaccurate, you have every right to explain your position. The key is to focus on facts rather than turning the discussion into an argument.

Ask questions, refer to documented results where appropriate, and explain any relevant context your manager may not have considered.

Try: “I see the situation differently. Could we review the project outcomes and the expectations we agreed on?”

A professional disagreement can help both parties reach a clearer understanding of performance expectations.

4. Blaming Colleagues or Other Departments

Avoid: “The project failed because the other team didn’t do its job.”

Your work may depend on other people, and it’s reasonable to discuss issues involving communication, handoffs, or shared responsibilities. However, personal criticism rarely helps resolve the underlying problem.

Focus on what happened, how it affected the outcome, and what could improve collaboration.

Try: “We experienced delays because some dependencies weren’t completed on schedule. I’d like to discuss how we can improve communication and clarify responsibilities on future projects.”

This keeps the conversation focused on solutions and demonstrates that you can work constructively across teams.

Questions to Ask Your Manager During a Performance Review

If you’re unsure how to keep the conversation moving, prepare a few questions in advance.

Consider asking:

  • What do you see as my most valuable contributions over the past year?
  • What should I prioritize during the next review period?
  • Which skills should I focus on developing?
  • What would demonstrate that I’m ready for greater responsibility?
  • Are there opportunities to work on projects that align with my career goals?
  • How often can we check in on my progress before the next formal review?

What Should You Do After a Performance Review?

The conversation shouldn’t end when the meeting does. Take a few minutes afterward to summarize what you discussed, including your manager’s feedback, agreed-upon goals, development opportunities, and any support they committed to providing.

Where appropriate, confirm the key action items with your manager so you both have a clear understanding of the next steps.

Break larger goals into manageable actions with realistic timelines. If you agreed to improve a particular skill, for example, identify the training or practical experience that will help you develop it.

Schedule follow-up conversations where possible. Regular check-ins can help you assess progress, address obstacles, and adjust priorities when circumstances change.

Make Your Performance Review Count

A performance review is more than an assessment of your past work. It’s an opportunity to communicate your contributions, understand your manager’s expectations, address challenges, and plan your professional development.

Prepare specific examples, ask thoughtful questions, and approach feedback with a willingness to learn. At the same time, remember that a productive conversation should allow you to explain your perspective and raise legitimate concerns.

If you’re considering your next career move, the discussion can also help you identify the skills and experience employers will expect at the next level.

Ready to take the next step in your career? Connect with IQ PARTNERS to learn more about our recruitment expertise and how we can help you explore your next opportunity.

More Insights About Performance Reviews

7 Concrete Steps to Take TODAY if You Didn’t Like Your Year-End Performance Review

Are Annual Performance Reviews a Thing of the Past?

How Long Should You Work Without a Raise or Promotion?

Steven Petroff Legal Recruiter

Steven Petroff

As a member of both our Accounting and Legal practices, Steven specializes in the recruitment of lawyers, law clerks, accountants, and investment advisors across a number of industries. Steven supports a large network of candidates as a LinkedIn Profile Expert and Career Coach.

Hire Better,
Hire Smarter
73.3% of our clients are repeat customers. They trust us to help them hire better.
Hire Better
The Smarter Way to Find Your Next Job
Because smart people make great companies.
Get Hired
Hire Better